Program Letter 26-1
TO: All Executive Directors
FROM: Will Gunn, Vice President for Legal Affairs and General Counsel
DATE: June 3, 2026
SUBJECT: Group Representation
Sample Group Eligibility Policy
Sample Group Eligibility Worksheet
Summary
Representation of groups is a small but significant part of some LSC grant recipients’ work. For those grant recipients who handle group cases, this work allows them to achieve certain mission objectives. For example, some recipients operate community economic development programs in which they represent neighborhood associations to increase affordable housing in under-resourced communities. Undertaking group representation also allows recipients to engage local law firms in pro bono work; for example, transactional attorneys may be more willing to help a local community nonprofit to incorporate than to provide individual representation. Several, if not all, of the LSC grant recipients who engage in group representation receive local, county, or state government funds to do this work, which allows them to do it without using LSC funds.
For LSC grant recipients who currently or want to engage in group representation, this program letter summarizes the regulatory requirements group applicants for legal representation must satisfy before an LSC grant recipient may accept their cases. Additionally, the program letter highlights best practices for determining when group representation is consistent with the grant recipient’s mission and priorities. In this section, LSC describes non-regulatory factors that grant recipients should consider when determining whether to accept a group client. In particular, LSC suggests grant recipients consider not only the potential reputational risk to their own organization, but also the risks to the larger LSC recipient network of accepting group cases brought by or involving parties whose activities may generate significant adverse public scrutiny.
Background
Group representation remains rare among LSC grantees. Between 2020 and 2024, 46 grant recipients closed at least one extended service group case, totaling 1,000 extended service group cases over the five-year period. These cases represented approximately 0.1% of all extended cases closed by LSC grantees during that period. Most of those grantees engaged in this work infrequently: 30 of the 46 grantees (65%) closed ten or fewer extended group cases across the entire five-year period.
Extended service group cases were also highly concentrated among a small number of programs. The grantee with the highest volume of extended service group cases during this period closed 189 cases, accounting for 18.9% of all extended group cases reported between 2020 and 2024. For that grantee, however, the 189 extended group cases represented approximately 3.3% of its total closed cases over the five-year period.
Although group cases remain relatively rare, they can have far-reaching impacts for the communities in which they are brought. Examples of successful group representation case outcomes include:
- A California grantee obtaining a decision finding that the State of California was required to replace CalFresh benefits lost through electronic theft; and
- A Missouri grantee advocating on behalf of several neighborhood associations to obtain title to abandoned, dilapidated homes; work with contractors to renovate and clean up the properties; and sell or rent the homes at affordable terms to members of the community.
Regulatory Requirements
Through its regulations in Title XVI of the Code of Federal Regulations, LSC has implemented statutory requirements for the kinds of clients LSC grant recipients may represent and the types of cases they may handle. Group representation implicates three of these requirements:
- 45 C.F.R. Part 1611—Financial Eligibility
45 C.F.R. Part 1620—Priorities
45 C.F.R. Part 1626—Restrictions on Legal Assistance to Aliens
A. Financial Eligibility under 45 C.F.R. § 1611.6
- The group, or its organizing/operating body if not a membership group, is primarily composed of individuals who would be financially eligible for LSC-funded legal assistance; or
- The group has as a principal activity the delivery of services to individuals in the community who would be financially eligible for LSC-funded legal assistance, and the legal help sought relates to that activity.
B. Required Documentation and Assessment
An organization receiving LSC funds must follow specific eligibility guidelines before providing LSC-funded legal assistance to groups, corporations, associations, or other entities. For groups seeking legal assistance, financial eligibility depends on demonstrating the lack of a practical means to retain legal counsel and showing that the group either consists primarily of financially eligible individuals or demonstrates that its principal activity is to serve such individuals.
An LSC grant recipient may use non-LSC funds to support legal assistance to an organization that does not demonstrate itself to be financially eligible. However, the organization may provide LSC-funded legal assistance to a group only if the group lacks the financial means to retain private counsel and has no practical means of obtaining funds to retain private counsel and meets one of two conditions:
To determine financial eligibility, an LSC grant recipient must:
- Evaluate the group’s financial resources, including income, assets, obligations, and income prospects, and either:
- For a group primarily composed of individuals who would be financially eligible for LSC-funded legal assistance, assess whether the financial or other socioeconomic characteristics of the group’s members are consistent with those who would be financially eligible for LSC-funded aid; or
- For a group having a principal activity of delivering services to those persons in the community who would be financially eligible for LSC-funded legal assistance, assess whether the financial and other socioeconomic characteristics of the persons served by the group are consistent with those who would be financially eligible for LSC-funded aid, and the assistance sought relates to the principal activity of the group.
- Collect and maintain sufficient documentation to reasonably demonstrate that the group meets the eligibility criteria.
C. Priorities under 45 C.F.R. Part 1620
Before accepting any case, including a group case, an LSC grant recipient must determine that accepting the case would be consistent with the recipient’s priorities. LSC requires grant recipients to set priorities using procedures that include “an effective appraisal of the needs of eligible clients. . .based on information received from potential or current eligible clients that is solicited in a manner reasonably calculated to obtain the views of all significant segments of the client population.” 45 C.F.R. § 1620.3(b). The recipient must also include information gleaned from “the recipient’s employees, governing body members, the private bar, and other interested persons.” Id. In addition to the information described above, the recipient must consider ten other factors in setting its priorities. Relevant factors include:
The resources of the recipient;
The availability of another source of free or low-cost legal assistance for a particular category of cases or matters;
The relative importance of particular legal problems to the individual clients of the recipient;
Whether legal efforts by the recipient will complement other efforts to solve particular problems in the area served; and
Whether legal efforts will result in efficient and economic delivery of legal services.
Id. § 1620.3(c). Finally, the recipient’s governing body must establish policies and procedures for accepting cases outside of the recipient’s priorities in emergency situations. Id. § 1620.4.
LSC grant recipients may only undertake group cases that either fit within their existing priorities or are emergencies as defined in the policies and procedures established by their governing bodies.
D. Eligibility Under 45 C.F.R. Part 1626
Although Part 1626 is silent regarding group clients, LSC has determined that organizations receiving LSC funds must determine a group’s eligibility under that regulation, regardless of whether LSC or non-LSC funds are used to support the legal assistance provided.
Using the framework of § 1611.6, as detailed in Advisory Opinion 2016-003, an LSC grant recipient may represent a group client only when the group either:
- Is primarily composed of individuals eligible under 45 C.F.R. Part 1626, or
- Has as a principal activity the delivery of services to persons in the community who would be eligible for services under Part 1626.
E. Required Documentation and Assessment
To determine eligibility under Part 1626, the grant recipient must evaluate whether:
- The group, or its organizing/operating body if it is not a membership group, is primarily composed of individuals who would be eligible for LSC-funded legal assistance under Part 1626; or
- The group has as a principal activity the delivery of services to individuals in the community who would be eligible for LSC-funded legal assistance, and the legal help sought relates directly to that activity.
The organization must collect and retain sufficient information to reasonably determine whether the group meets one of the criteria described above.
Best Practices
Through interviews with leaders at LSC grant recipients that regularly employ group representation as part of their service delivery model and handle the most group cases among LSC grant recipients, LSC has identified several best practices. All grantees interviewed indicated that a central factor in deciding to accept a certain group as a client is the reputational risk, if any, to the grant recipient of representing the group. Although not expressly raised by the group LSC consulted, LSC believes that in deciding whether to undertake a group case, grant recipients should also consider whether doing so is in the best interest of the LSC grantee network as a whole, including any potential reputational risks. Additionally, for cases that may involve an elevated level of reputational risk, it may be to the benefit of the LSC grantee network to use non-LSC funds to support the case.
Grantees should consider adopting the following practices for group cases.
- Have a written policy specific to evaluating group cases for acceptance. The policy may include:
- Review and/or final approval by two or more members of the grant recipient’s leadership team (e.g., managing attorney, director of litigation, Executive Director). For example, if it is an extended services case involving litigation, the final decision on acceptance is usually made by the Executive Director.
- Review of external sources to verify the group applicant’s financial eligibility, such as 990s, annual reports, or charity evaluation sites (e.g., GuideStar, Charity Navigator).
- Review of the group’s website and social media presence.
- Conduct a web search of the organization to identify potential risks to accepting or rejecting the group’s case.
- For long-term group clients:
- Annually check secretary of state or other responsible agency’s website to ensure the group remains in good standing.
- Annually reevaluate the group’s financial eligibility.
- Evaluate the risk(s) to the grant recipient and the LSC grantee network of accepting or rejecting the group’s case. Factors to consider include:
- The nature of the case, e.g., whether the group is asking for transactional assistance or representation in litigation.
- The group’s reputation in the community. This factor may include things such as whether the group is under scrutiny for allegations of mismanagement or malfeasance and whether the assistance sought is related to remediating the allegations.
- Whether the grantee is the organization best situated to undertake the group’s case, given the subject of the case and the availability of other lawyers to represent the group’s interests.
- The grantee’s expertise in handling the kind of case for which the group is seeking assistance. For example, if the group is a non-profit domestic violence shelter seeking assistance to quash a subpoena for records of shelter clients, and the grantee is highly experienced in subpoena defense for this type of group.
- Whether the other party or parties in the case are associated with controversial views. For example, if a group applicant approaches an LSC grant recipient to represent the interests of its members in a lawsuit brought by a party or parties associated with causes that may generate significant adverse public scrutiny, the grantee should consider how its participation in the case would be perceived. This analysis should extend beyond the grant recipient’s immediate community and consider the effect on the LSC grant recipient network more broadly.
- Evaluate whether the case is consistent with the grantee’s mission. For example, if a grantee has a community economic development project through which it helps small businesses incorporate, the grantee may consider whether the type of business would be consistent with the grantee’s own mission. Helping a childcare center, restaurant, or bookstore to incorporate may be consistent with the grantee’s mission, while helping a bar, liquor store, or payday loan servicer to incorporate may not.
A sample group eligibility policy and a sample group eligibility worksheet are included with this Program Letter. The use of these templates is not mandatory. If you have questions about this guidance or about accepting a group case, please contact your assigned program counsel in the Office of Compliance and Enforcement.
1 The Preamble to the regulation at 70 FR 45545, 45557 (September 7, 2005) defines the term “primarily composed” to mean, “[i]n the case of membership groups, at least a majority of the members would have to be individuals who would be financially eligible [and eligible under Part 1626]; in the case of non-membership groups, at least a majority of members of the governing body would have to be individuals who would be financially eligible [and eligible under Part 1626].” In Advisory Opinion 2016-03, LSC stated that “the recipient does not need to conduct individual Part 1626 determinations for a specific number of group members.” The Opinion went on to state that the recipient should ‘collect information that reasonably demonstrates that the group . . . meets the eligibility criteria set forth herein.” 45 C.F.R. § 1611.6(b)(2).
2The requirements of 45 C.F.R. Part 1626 do not apply to the use of tribal funds so long as the tribal funds are being used for the group being represented and such use is in accordance with the specific purposes for which the tribal funds were provided. See Advisory Opinion 2013-08.
